Why Your Toilet Isn’t Flushing Right: It Could Be the Handle

September 29, 2025

When a toilet stops flushing properly, most people assume it’s a problem inside the tank — maybe a worn flapper, broken chain, or faulty fill valve. While those are common issues, there’s one simple part that often gets overlooked: the handle. If your toilet isn’t flushing smoothly, feels stiff, loose, or just doesn’t work like it used to, the issue might be the wrong replacement handle.

Why the Right Toilet Handle Matters

Toilet handles aren’t one-size-fits-all. Each brand designs its flushing system with a specific shape, angle, and function in mind. Replacing a broken handle with a generic one from the hardware store may seem like an easy fix, but in many cases, it causes more problems than it solves.

Here’s why:

Improper fit – Generic handles might not align with the internal parts properly. This affects how the flush lever pulls the chain or lifts the flapper.
Weak flush – If the handle doesn’t give full lift to the flapper, you’ll get a partial flush or have to hold the handle down.
Increased wear – Misaligned or cheap handles can put extra strain on the internal components of the tank, leading to faster wear and potential leaks.

Kohler Toilets: Always Use Matching Parts

Kohler is a well-known and trusted brand when it comes to toilets and bathroom fixtures. But their systems are built with precision and often require Kohler-brand handles or compatible OEM replacements.

Using an off-brand or “universal” handle may result in:

Improper flushing
Tank leaks
Handle that sticks or falls off
Frustrating double flushing or water waste

If you have a Kohler toilet, we recommend only using a matching Kohler handle. It may cost a few dollars more, but it saves you from future repairs and wasted water.

Signs You May Have the Wrong Handle

Not sure if your toilet handle is causing issues? Here are a few things to look for:

You have to jiggle the handle after flushing
Flushes are weak or incomplete
The chain keeps falling off
You need to hold the handle down for a full flush
Water runs longer than it should

If you’ve recently replaced the handle and now have one or more of these issues, there’s a good chance the new handle doesn’t match your toilet’s flush system.

Professional Toilet Repair Done Right

At Demmis Plumbing, we take the guesswork out of toilet repairs. Whether it’s a simple handle replacement or a full internal rebuild, we make sure the job’s done right:

We identify the make and model of your toilet
We use brand-specific replacement parts (like Kohler, American Standard, Toto, and more)
We test the system thoroughly to ensure a proper flush
We clean up after ourselves — no mess left behind

A toilet that works properly saves water, reduces frustration, and avoids costly damage down the line.

Don’t Let a Small Part Cause a Big Problem

It’s easy to ignore a sticking handle or weak flush — until it becomes a bigger plumbing issue. Whether you’re dealing with a persistent toilet problem or just want peace of mind, our licensed plumbers are ready to help.

Call Demmis Plumbing today for expert toilet repair and service.

📞 Need a plumber? We’re here to help.

📍 Serving Chicago Southwest Suburbs

Remember, Demmis Plumbing is here for you, offering both standard and emergency plumbing services.

Sewer Line Inspection, Clogged Sewer Line, Sewer Problems, Plumbing Inspection, Backed Up Plumbing, Emergency Plumbing, Plumbing Services, Sewer Line Repair, Plumbing Solutions, Lemont IL Plumbing, Drainage Issues, Pipe Inspection, Plumbing Emergency, Tree Root Damage, Plumbing Repair, Prevent Sewer Blockages

www.demmisplumbing.com